The perception of periods a qualitative study into the. And giving your daughter and even your son some books about menstruation is a wonderful way to start talking. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. In this exclusive extract from holly griggspalls book, sweetening the pill. A questionandanswer format in the last three chapters allows girls to locate easily the information they seek. Graphic4 menstruation is one of the most prominent anthropological taboos to have left its mark on present day society. Without the promise of 10 or 12 children to bear, menstruation, according to. Since coutinho and segals 1999 publication of the provocative book is menstruation obsolete how suppressing menstruation can help women who suffer from anemia, endometriosis or pms, the notion of menstrual suppression has been actively discussed and debated amongst women, medical professionals and scholars alike.
However, periods may occasionally start as young as eight years old and still be considered normal. Articles in the professional and popular press have asserted that menstrual suppression is a reasonable lifestyle choice. Moreover, they propose that suppressing menstruation has remarkable health advantages. How suppressing menstruation can help women who suffer from anemia, endometriosis, orpms.
Elsimar coutinho polarized the womens health community with the publication of is menstruation obsolete. Discover 5 little known, yet crucial facts about our smritis such as the manu smriti the old smritis such as the manusmriti are now obsolete. Menstrual suppression has been recommended for medical conditions such as endometriosis, but it is also being proposed as a lifestyle choice for women who dislike menstruation or find it inconvenient. Moreover, they propose that suppressing menstruation has remarkable health.
However, the author, a pioneer in the development and. Elibrary welcome to the cwhn womens health database, our comprehensive bilingual collection of womens health publications and resources from across canada and the world. It is time to write a new smriti according to the need of the present age. Inappropriate the list including its title or description facilitates illegal activity, or contains hate speech or ad hominem attacks on a fellow goodreads member or author. In the spring of 1963, just after rocks book was published, a meeting was held at the vatican between high officials of the catholic church and donald b. Sheldon j segal the authors argue that regular monthly bleeding is not the natural state of women, and that it actually places them at risk of several medical conditions of varying severity. Books online at best prices in india by sheldon j segal,elsimar m coutinho from. The first period usually begins between twelve and fifteen years of age, a point in time known as menarche.
Forms a group wishing to raise awareness surrounding menstrual girlbody politics. Coutinho claims that women menstruated a lot less in the past because of pregnancy, poor nutrition, nursing, and so on, and says menstruation has no proven benefit to those not trying to conceive a child. In industrial societies the average woman has few children and therefore may have 450 menstrual cycles during a lifetime. The argument has merit for women with specific diseases such as endometriosis or anemia caused by menorrhagia. Women have evolved past the need for menstruation, goes this questionable argument, and now should be relieved of the. This book by a brazilian gynaecologist, translated for the north american market, is intended for the lay person. News, 29 august 1999, at the museum of menstruation and. Since the 1960s, advances in hormonebased contraception have, by suppressing ovulation, challenged the biological necessity of monthly periods. The case against menstruation was laid out in the book is menstruation obsolete. Along with those changes have come ways to deal with menstruation. Menstruation, also known as a period or monthly, is the regular discharge of blood and mucosal tissue known as menses from the inner lining of the uterus through the vagina. The main premise of this provocative book is that menstruation is unpleasant, unnecessary, and even unhealthy.
Women have evolved past the need for menstruation, goes this questionable argument, and now should be relieved of the problem of an unnecessary monthly loss of blood. Janet benshoof, president, center for reproductive law and policy is menstruation obsolete. By using this unique isbn code, readers can search for a book more accurately. In the book, coutinho argues that the contemporary woman has many more periods than nature likely intended. Or how we got hooked on hormonal birth control the inspiration for a documentary project from ricki lake and abby epstein, the author, who is also our fierce woman of the month, discusses the medical importance of healthy menstruation and reveals how a culture that denies the necessity of this bodily. Brazilian gynecology professor elsimar coutinho, in his book is menstruation obsolete. And a huge part of puberty for many is getting their first period. This uprecedented scientific analysis of the health and social consequences and roledefining power of menstruation is certian to. Read another opinion in favor of stopping, by the brazilian physician who is the author of is menstruation obsolete. Incorrect book the list contains an incorrect book please specify the title of the book.
In a controversial book published by oxford university press, coutinho suggests that menstruation is an unhealthy and unnecessary process that causes women countless health and emotional problems. Women who are menstruating have been branded as impure and, in a not too distant past, were accused of turning cows milk sour or. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read is menstruation obsolete. The menstrual machine is the machine that produces all that is. He answers the question is menstruation obsolete with a resounding yes. Spam or selfpromotional the list is spam or selfpromotional. He advocates a campaign to educate the public about the uselessness of menstruation for women not actively seeking pregnancy. Birth controls effect on menstruation maxim hygiene. The international standard book number isbn of is menstruation obsolete. Birth control options that reduce or eliminate periods are. Coutinho, 9780195218, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. The book uses diagrams to familiarize readers with the inner workings of their bodies, including what happens during menstruation. The authors maintain that while menstruation may be culturally significant, it is not medically meaningful. Coutinho gynecology, obstetrics and human reproductionfederal university of bahia school of medicine in brazil first advanced this startling opinion in a 1996 portuguese edition of this work.
A groundbreaking book that proposes that menstruation is medically unnecessary and that suppressing it has tremendous health benefits. A parents guide bound into the back suggests how to begin a conversation about puberty, what to cover. Segal,he writes that modern women experience incessant ovulation, in. In a controversial book newly published by oxford university press, coutinho.
704 605 1553 353 574 1478 828 1086 1307 1481 887 329 1474 1445 1375 985 1098 1218 615 725 835 722 368 856 1330 456 759 417 483 668 1127 36 1004 1263 596 78 1174